TyreReviews test of all-season All-Terrain (A/T) tires 265/70 R17 2026

Choosing the right All-Terrain (A/T) tires for pickups, SUVs and off-roaders is always about finding the perfect compromise. On the one hand, you want an aggressive look, durable construction and uncompromising off-road grip, but on the other hand, you don't want to risk dangerous skidding on wet asphalt or suffer from unbearable highway noise.

Specialized website Tyre Reviews has prepared its most detailed test of off-road tires to date. The testing lasted almost a year – from winter snow and ice in Northern Europe, through wet and dry tracks in Central Europe, to dusty and rocky off-road in Utah, USA.

The size tested was the popular 265/70 R17 and the main test vehicle was the Ford Ranger Raptor. The test involved 6 modern aggressive A/T tires, 1 budget alternative (Westlake) and the Pirelli Scorpion AS Plus 3 all-season all-road tire as a reference model.

If you're looking for a tire that pushes the boundaries of overall All-Terrain performance, the new Pirelli Scorpion XTM AT is the clear choice.

• Best in the field : She achieved the fastest time on the dusty and rocky track (74.05 s) and received the highest subjective rating from the riders (8.6/10).
• Unrivaled safety on water : Among A/T tires, it demonstrated the shortest braking distance in the wet (35.77 m) and the fastest lap time.
• Perfect readability on snow : It was among the best in winter disciplines and provided readable behavior when transitioning into a skid.

Verdict : If you want the best A/T tire available today without compromise on water or off-road, buy the Pirelli Scorpion XTM AT.

The Nokian Outpost nAT tire has shown that while other A/T tires tend to be noisy and harsh, off-road tires can be extremely comfortable.

• Quietest and most comfortable : Along with the road reference tire, it received the highest scores for noise and shock absorption.
• King of aquaplaning : In deep water, it achieved the best results among all A/T tires tested.
• Confidence in winter conditions : Nokian's Finnish roots have not been denied - it offers great balance in the snow without unnecessary drama.

Verdict : An ideal choice for drivers looking for the best balance of on-road comfort, excellent snow performance, and off-road reliability.

The iconic BFGoodrich tread pattern has received a new generation KO3. In the test, it confirmed its traditional strengths, but also showed its weak points on the asphalt.

• Perfect work in ruts and terrain : The tire carcass absorbs uneven terrain perfectly and brakes excellently on dusty surfaces.
• Surprisingly quiet ride : On regular asphalt, it was unexpectedly quiet and comfortable.
• Dry braking : In braking tests from 100 km/h on dry asphalt, it finished in last place (47.06 m).

Verdict : A traditionally robust and durable tire for those who require a solid build for rocks and challenging terrain.

The Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac RT tire was designed with a clear focus on winter traction.

• Snow Champion : Achieved the fastest time on a snowy track and the shortest braking distance on snow.
• Slightly harder on bumps : Off-road and on uneven asphalt, it feels a little firmer and less flexible.

The Westlake tire was included in the test as a cheap, less aggressive representative.

• Wet road : A pleasant surprise was 3rd place in wet handling and great braking performance on water (37.25 m).
• Acoustic & Off-road : It has weaker sidewall stability off-road and produces an unpleasant high-pitched tone on the highway.

Are modern A/T tires safe enough for winter?

Top models like the Goodyear DuraTrac RT, Pirelli Scorpion XTM AT, and Nokian Outpost nAT perform excellently on snow and provide a high level of control. However, beware of models like the Falken A/T4W, which lag significantly in winter.

What is the difference between noise on paper and in reality?

As the test on the cheaper Westlake tire showed, the measured volume in decibels may not mean everything. What matters is the frequency (tone) of the noise - tires like Nokian or BFGoodrich are able to suppress unpleasant tones very well.

• If you want the best A/T tires on the market (off-road, wet, snow) Choose the Pirelli Scorpion XTM AT .
• If you are looking for maximum comfort on the road, silence and great performance in winter, reach for the Nokian Outpost nAT .
• If you require traditional, durable construction for rocks and ruts, choose the BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A KO3 .

Are you planning to fit your 4x4 or SUV with new All-Terrain tires? Check out our offer in the e-shop or contact us for professional help in choosing the right size!